The Miracle Examiners solve the mystery of the statue's tears, and learn of the founding of the abbey by the highly revered and compassionate Father Michael Brown who rescued orphaned children after the war in Europe. However two new murders occur, Father Francesco is strangled to death and Father Joseph is crucified upside-down. Hiraga and Roberto think that there is a war between good and evil part being played out in the abbey and the answers lie in the abbey's ancient history.